Constitution As A Living DocumentClass 11 India Constitution At Work Case Study Questions
15 Questions
Generated by KedovoAI
Case 1 of 15
Case Study7 marks
The Nature of a Living Constitution
It is not uncommon for nations to rewrite their constitutions in response to changed circumstances or change of ideas within the society or even due to political upheavals. The Soviet Union had four constitutions in its life of 74 years. In 1991, the rule of the Communist Party came to an end and the newly formed Russian federation adopted a new constitution in 1993. France had numerous constitutions in the last two centuries. But look at India. The Constitution of India was adopted on 26 November 1949. More than 69 years after that, the same constitution continues to function. One of the answers to this is that our Constitution accepts the necessity of modifications according to changing needs of the society. Secondly, in the actual working of the Constitution, there has been enough flexibility of interpretations. Both political practice and judicial rulings have shown maturity and flexibility in implementing the Constitution. These factors have made our Constitution a living document rather than a closed and static rulebook.
Questions on this case
1(1 mark)MCQ
According to the passage, which of the following countries had four constitutions in 74 years?
2(1 mark)
What is meant by a 'living document' in the context of the Indian Constitution?
3(2 marks)
What are the two main factors contributing to the durability of the Indian Constitution, as mentioned in the passage?
4(1 mark)MCQ
What distinguishes India's constitutional history from that of France and the former Soviet Union?
5(2 marks)
How do political practice and judicial rulings contribute to making the Constitution a 'living document'?
Case Study7 marks
The Amendment Procedure
The makers of our Constitution wanted to strike a balance. The Constitution must be amended if so required. But it must be protected from unnecessary and frequent changes. In other words, they wanted the Constitution to be 'flexible' and at the same time 'rigid'. Flexible means open to changes and rigid means resistant to changes. A constitution that can be very easily changed is called flexible. In the case of constitutions, which are very difficult to amend, they are described as rigid. The Indian Constitution combines both these characteristics. For amending the remaining parts of the Constitution, provision has been made in Article 368 of the Constitution. In this article, there are two methods of amending the Constitution... One method is that amendment can be made by special majority of the two houses of the Parliament. The other method is more difficult: it requires special majority of the Parliament and consent of half of the State legislatures. Note that all amendments to the Constitution are initiated only in the Parliament.
Questions on this case
1(1 mark)MCQ
What does the term 'flexible' mean in the context of a constitution?
2(1 mark)
Which article of the Constitution deals with the procedure for amendments?
3(2 marks)
What are the two methods of amending the Constitution mentioned in the passage under Article 368?
4(1 mark)MCQ
Where can a constitutional amendment bill be initiated?
5(2 marks)
Explain the 'balance' that the makers of the Indian Constitution sought to achieve regarding the amendment process.
Case Study7 marks
The Principle of Special Majority
Amendment to the Constitution requires two different kinds of special majorities: in the first place, those voting in favour of the amendment bill should constitute at least half of the total strength of that House. Secondly, the supporters of the amendment bill must also constitute two-thirds of those who actually take part in voting. Both Houses of the Parliament must pass the amendment bill separately in this same manner (there is no provision for a joint session). For every amendment bill, this special majority is required. Can you see the significance of this requirement? In the Lok Sabha there are 545 members. Therefore, any amendment must be supported by a minimum of 273 members. Even if only 300 members are present at the time of voting, the amendment bill must get the support of 273 out of them. The basic principle behind the amending procedure is that it should be based on broad support among the political parties and parliamentarians.
Questions on this case
1(1 mark)MCQ
What is the first condition of the special majority required for a constitutional amendment?
2(1 mark)
What is the second condition of the special majority?
3(2 marks)
If 450 members of the Lok Sabha are present and voting on an amendment bill, what is the minimum number of 'yes' votes required for it to pass, considering both conditions?
4(1 mark)MCQ
What happens if the two Houses of Parliament disagree on an amendment bill?
5(2 marks)
What is the underlying principle or significance of requiring a special majority for constitutional amendments?