JudiciaryClass 11 India Constitution At Work Case Study Questions
10 Questions
Generated by KedovoAI
Case 1 of 10
Case Study7 marks
The Independence of the Indian Judiciary
In order to be able to protect the rule of law and ensure the supremacy of law, it is necessary that the judiciary is independent of any political pressures. The Indian Constitution has ensured the independence of the judiciary through a number of measures. The legislature is not involved in the process of appointment of judges. The judges have a fixed tenure and hold office till reaching the age of retirement. The Constitution prescribes a very difficult procedure for the removal of judges, providing them with security of tenure. Furthermore, the judiciary is not financially dependent on either the executive or legislature, as the salaries and allowances of the judges are not subjected to the approval of the legislature. The actions and decisions of the judges are immune from personal criticisms, and the judiciary has the power to penalise those found guilty of contempt of court. This ensures that judges can perform their functions without fear or favour. However, independence does not imply arbitrariness; the judiciary is accountable to the Constitution, democratic traditions, and the people.
Questions on this case
1(1 mark)MCQ
Which of the following is a measure ensured by the Constitution to maintain judicial independence?
2(1 mark)
What is the principal role of the judiciary that necessitates its independence?
3(2 marks)
Why is the judiciary's financial independence from the legislature significant?
4(1 mark)MCQ
The power to penalise for 'contempt of court' serves as a protection for judges against what?
5(2 marks)
The passage states that independence of the judiciary does not imply 'arbitrariness or absence of accountability'. To whom or what is the judiciary accountable?
Case Study7 marks
The Appointment of Judges
The appointment of judges has never been free from political controversy. Initially, the other Judges of the Supreme Court and the High Courts were appointed by the President after 'consulting' the Chief Justice of India (CJI). This in effect meant that the final decisions rested with the Council of Ministers, as the court initially felt the CJI's role was purely consultative. However, this interpretation evolved. The Supreme Court later took the view that the opinion of the Chief Justice must be followed by the President. Finally, the Court came up with a novel procedure, suggesting that the Chief Justice should recommend names for appointment in consultation with the four senior-most judges of the Court. This established the principle of 'collegiality' in making recommendations. Thus, in matters of appointment to the judiciary, the decision of this group of senior judges (the collegium) now carries greater weight, creating a system where the Supreme Court and the Council of Ministers both play an important role.
Questions on this case
1(1 mark)MCQ
Who appoints the judges of the Supreme Court and the High Courts?
2(1 mark)
What was the initial status of the CJI's consultation in the appointment process?
3(2 marks)
What is the 'principle of collegiality' established by the Supreme Court?
4(1 mark)MCQ
How did the Supreme Court's interpretation of 'consultation' change over time?
5(2 marks)
Evaluate why the appointment of judges is considered a political process, based on the passage.
Case Study7 marks
An Unsuccessful Attempt to Remove a Judge
The removal of judges of the Supreme Court and High Courts is extremely difficult, requiring a motion approved by a special majority in both Houses of Parliament on grounds of proven misbehaviour or incapacity. In 1991, the first-ever motion to remove a Supreme Court Justice, V. Ramaswami, was initiated. He was accused of misappropriating funds during his tenure as Chief Justice of the Punjab and Haryana High Court. A high-profile inquiry commission of Supreme Court judges found him 'guilty of wilful and gross misuses of office'. Despite this strong indictment, Justice Ramaswami survived the parliamentary motion. The motion received the required two-thirds majority among members present and voting. However, the Congress party abstained from voting. Consequently, the motion could not get the support of one-half of the total strength of the House, a necessary condition for the special majority, and the judge was not removed. This case highlights the crucial role of the legislature in the removal process and the difficulty in achieving the required consensus.
Questions on this case
1(1 mark)MCQ
On what grounds can a judge of the Supreme Court be removed?
2(1 mark)
What was Justice V. Ramaswami accused of?
3(2 marks)
Why did the motion to remove Justice Ramaswami fail in Parliament?
4(1 mark)MCQ
The failure to remove Justice Ramaswami highlights the importance of what factor in the removal process?
5(2 marks)
What does the V. Ramaswami case demonstrate about the principle of 'security of tenure' for judges?