Rights In The Indian ConstitutionClass 11 India Constitution At Work Case Study Questions
10 Questions
Generated by KedovoAI
Case 1 of 10
Case Study7 marks
The Plight of Machal Lalung
Machal Lalung was 23 when he was arrested. A resident of Chuburi village of Morigaon district of Assam, Machal was charged of causing grievous injuries. He was found mentally too unstable to stand trial and was sent as under trial to Lok Priya Gopinath Bordoloi Mental Hospital in Tejpur for treatment. Machal was treated successfully and doctors wrote twice to jail authorities in 1967 and 1996 that he was fit to stand trial. But no one paid any attention. Machal Lalung remained in "judicial custody." Machal Lalung was released in July 2005. He was 77 then. He spent 54 years under custody during which his case never came up for hearing. He was freed when a team appointed by the National Human Rights Commission intervened after an inspection of undertrials in the State. Machal's entire life was wasted because a proper trial against him never took place. Our Constitution gives every citizen the right to 'life and liberty': this means that every citizen must also have the right to fair and speedy trial. Machal's case shows what happens when rights granted by the Constitution are not available in practice.
Questions on this case
1(1 mark)MCQ
For how long did Machal Lalung remain in custody?
2(1 mark)MCQ
Which fundamental right, explicitly mentioned in the passage, includes the right to a fair and speedy trial?
3(1 mark)
Why did Machal Lalung's case never go to trial despite doctors declaring him fit?
4(2 marks)
What does Machal Lalung's case demonstrate about constitutional rights?
5(2 marks)
How was Machal Lalung eventually freed, and what does this imply about protecting rights?
Case Study7 marks
The Concept of a Bill of Rights
A democracy must ensure that individuals have certain rights and that the government will always recognise these rights. Therefore it is often a practice in most democratic countries to list the rights of the citizens in the constitution itself. Such a list of rights mentioned and protected by the constitution is called the 'bill of rights'. A bill of rights prohibits government from thus acting against the rights of the individuals and ensures a remedy in case there is violation of these rights. The rights of a person may be threatened by another person or private organisation. In such a situation, the individual would need the protection of the government. So, it is necessary that the government is bound to protect the rights of the individual. On the other hand, the organs of the government (the legislature, executive, bureaucracy or even the judiciary), in the course of their functioning, may violate the rights of the person.
Questions on this case
1(1 mark)MCQ
What is a 'bill of rights'?
2(1 mark)MCQ
According to the passage, who can threaten the rights of a person?
3(1 mark)
What is the primary function of a bill of rights in relation to the government?
4(2 marks)
Why is it necessary for the government to be bound to protect individual rights?
5(2 marks)
The passage mentions that even the judiciary can violate rights. How does a bill of rights, as described, address this possibility?
Case Study6 marks
Understanding the Right to Equality
Consider the following two situations. These are imaginary situations. But similar things do happen and can happen.
- Swadesh Kumar is visiting his village. He is accompanied by one of his friends. They decided to have a cup of tea at the village roadside hotel. The shopkeeper knew Swadesh Kumar but asked the name of his friend to know his caste. After this the shopkeeper served tea to Swadesh Kumar in a nice mug while his friend was given tea in an earthen cup because he was dalit.
- An order is served to four newsreaders of a television channel that they would no longer read the news on screen. They are all women. The reason given is that they are above the age of forty-five. Two male newsreaders above the same age are not barred from presenting the news. These are examples of clear discrimination. In one instance the discrimination is based on caste and in another it is based on gender. Right to equality tries to do away with such and other discriminations. It provides for equal access to public places like shops, hotels, places of entertainment, wells, bathing ghats and places of worship.
Questions on this case
1(1 mark)MCQ
In the first situation, on what basis was Swadesh Kumar's friend discriminated against?
2(1 mark)
What was the basis for discrimination in the case of the television newsreaders?
3(1 mark)
Which fundamental right is being violated in both of these situations?
4(1 mark)MCQ
The Right to Equality prohibits discrimination in access to public places on grounds of religion, race, caste, sex, or...
5(2 marks)
How does the action of the shopkeeper in the first scenario directly contravene the provisions of the Right to Equality as explained in the passage?