The Philosophy Of The ConstitutionClass 11 India Constitution At Work Case Study Questions
10 Questions
Generated by KedovoAI
Case 1 of 10
Case Study7 marks
The Political Philosophy of the Constitution
Some people believe that a constitution merely consists of laws and that laws are one thing, values and morality, quite another. Therefore, we can have only a legalistic, not a political philosophy approach to the Constitution. It is true that all laws do not have a moral content, but many laws are closely connected to our deeply held values. For example, a law might prohibit discrimination of persons on grounds of language or religion. Such a law is connected to the idea of equality. Such a law exists because we value equality. Therefore, there is a connection between laws and moral values. We must therefore, look upon the constitution as a document that is based on a certain moral vision. We need to adopt a political philosophy approach to the constitution. This means we must understand the conceptual structure of the constitution, work out a coherent vision of society based on it, and read it in conjunction with the Constituent Assembly Debates to understand the justification of its embedded values.
Questions on this case
1(1 mark)MCQ
According to the passage, a law prohibiting discrimination is connected to which value?
2(1 mark)
What is the legalistic approach to the Constitution mentioned in the passage?
3(2 marks)
What are the three things involved in adopting a political philosophy approach to the constitution, as per the text?
4(1 mark)MCQ
The passage argues against which of the following ideas?
5(2 marks)
Why is it important to adopt a political philosophy approach rather than a purely legalistic one when studying the Constitution? Explain in your own words based on the passage.
Case Study7 marks
Indian Secularism and Principled Distance
The mainstream, western conception, of secularism means mutual exclusion of state and religion. The term 'mutual exclusion' means this: both religion and state must stay away from the internal affairs of one another. The state must not intervene in the domain of religion; religion likewise should not dictate state policy. Conditions in India were different. The makers of the Constitution had to work out an alternative conception of secularism. They departed from the western model because religiously sanctioned customs such as untouchability deprived individuals of basic dignity. Without active state intervention, there was no hope of their dissolution. The state simply had to interfere in the affairs of religion. The state could also help religious communities by giving aid to educational institutions run by them. Thus, the state may help or hinder religious communities depending on which mode of action promotes values such as freedom and equality. In India, separation between religion and state did not mean their mutual exclusion but rather principled distance.
Questions on this case
1(1 mark)MCQ
What does the western conception of secularism mean?
2(1 mark)
Why did the Indian Constitution depart from the western model of secularism?
3(2 marks)
The Indian model of secularism allows the state to interfere in religious affairs. Give one example of a negative intervention and one of a positive intervention mentioned in the passage.
4(1 mark)MCQ
The concept that best describes the Indian model of secularism, according to the passage, is:
5(2 marks)
Explain the concept of 'principled distance'. How does it promote values like freedom and equality?
Case Study7 marks
Criticism of the Constitution as an 'Alien' Document
A final criticism alleges that the Indian Constitution is entirely an alien document, borrowed article by article from western constitutions and sits uneasily with the cultural ethos of the Indian people. This criticism is often voiced by many. Even in the Constituent Assembly itself, K. Hanumanthaiya argued, '...we wanted the music of Veena or Sitar, but here we have the music of an English band.' However, this charge is not entirely true. It is true that the Indian Constitution is modern and partly western. But it was never a blind borrowing; it was innovative borrowing. Many Indians have not only adopted modern ways of thinking, but have made these their own. For Dalits, westernisation became a form of protest against the filth in their own tradition. Furthermore, when western modernity began to interact with local cultural systems, a hybrid culture began to emerge, possibly by creative adaptation. This was a process of selective adaptation and not borrowing.
Questions on this case
1(1 mark)MCQ
What is the main criticism of the Indian Constitution discussed in the passage?
2(1 mark)
Who in the Constituent Assembly compared the Constitution to 'the music of an English band'?
3(2 marks)
How did some social groups, like Dalits, perceive 'westernisation' according to the text?
4(1 mark)MCQ
The passage describes the process of creating the Constitution as:
5(2 marks)
Evaluate the argument that the Indian Constitution is a 'borrowed' document. Is this criticism fair? Justify your answer based on the passage.