EqualityClass 11 Political Theory Case Study Questions
10 Questions
Generated by KedovoAI
Case 1 of 10
Case Study7 marks
Natural vs. Social Inequalities
A distinction has sometimes been made in political theory between natural inequalities and socially-produced inequalities. Natural inequalities are those that emerge between people as a result of their different capabilities and talents. These kinds of inequalities are different from socially-produced inequalities which emerge as a consequence of inequalities of opportunity or the exploitation of some groups in a society by others. Natural inequalities are considered to be the result of the different characteristics and abilities with which people are born. It is generally assumed that natural differences cannot be altered. Social inequalities on the other hand are those created by society. Certain societies may, for instance, value those who perform intellectual work over those who do manual work and reward them differently. Differences of this kind reflect the values of a society and some of these may certainly appear to us to be unjust. This distinction is sometimes useful in helping us to distinguish between acceptable and unfair inequalities in society but it is not always clear or self-evident. For instance, advances in medical science and technologies have helped many disabled people to function effectively in society.
Questions on this case
1(1 mark)MCQ
According to the passage, natural inequalities are based on:
2(1 mark)
What are socially-produced inequalities?
3(2 marks)
Why is the distinction between natural and social inequalities not always clear?
4(1 mark)MCQ
How have advances in medical science and technology challenged the idea of 'natural differences' being unalterable?
5(2 marks)
Evaluate why it might be unjust to deny a disabled person help on the grounds that their disability is 'natural'. Use the information in the passage to support your answer.
Case Study6 marks
Affirmative Action and Its Critiques
Affirmative action is based on the idea that it is not sufficient to establish formal equality by law. When we wish to eliminate inequalities that are deeply rooted, it is necessary to take some more positive measures to minimise and eliminate entrenched forms of social inequalities. Most policies of affirmative action are thus designed to correct the cumulative effect of past inequalities. In our country we have adopted a policy of quotas or reserved seats in education and jobs to provide equality of opportunity to deprived groups. The policy has been defended on the ground that certain groups have been victims of social prejudice and discrimination. These communities who have suffered in the past and been denied equal opportunities cannot be immediately expected to compete with others on equal terms. Critics of positive discrimination, particularly policies of reservations, invoke the principle of equality to argue against such policies. They contend that any provision of reservations or quotas for the deprived is unfair as it arbitrarily denies other sections of society their right to equal treatment. They maintain that reservations are a form of reverse discrimination.
Questions on this case
1(1 mark)MCQ
What is the fundamental idea behind affirmative action?
2(1 mark)
According to the passage, what is the primary purpose of affirmative action policies?
3(1 mark)
What argument is used to defend the policy of quotas or reservations in India?
4(1 mark)MCQ
Critics of affirmative action often describe it as a form of:
5(2 marks)
Explain the paradox where critics of affirmative action use the 'principle of equality' to argue against it. How can a policy meant to promote equality be seen as a violation of it?
Case Study7 marks
The Three Dimensions of Equality
While identifying different kinds of inequalities that exist in society, various thinkers and ideologies have highlighted three main dimensions of equality namely, political, social and economic. It is only by addressing each of these three different dimensions of equality can we move towards a more just and equal society. In democratic societies political equality would normally include granting equal citizenship to all members of the state, bringing with it rights such as the right to vote and freedom of expression. Social equality requires that people belonging to different groups and communities also have a fair and equal chance to compete for goods and opportunities. For this, it is necessary to minimise the effects of social and economic inequalities and guarantee certain minimum conditions of life to all, like adequate health care and the opportunity for good education. Economic inequality exists if there are significant differences in wealth, property or income between individuals or classes.
Questions on this case
1(1 mark)MCQ
Which dimension of equality includes the right to vote and freedom of expression?
2(1 mark)
List two minimum conditions of life that are necessary for social equality, according to the passage.
3(2 marks)
The passage suggests that political equality alone is not enough to build a just society. Why?
4(1 mark)MCQ
Significant differences in wealth, property, or income between individuals or classes are characteristic of:
5(2 marks)
Evaluate the statement: 'It is only by addressing each of these three different dimensions of equality can we move towards a more just and equal society.' How are the three dimensions interconnected?