Social JusticeClass 11 Political Theory Case Study Questions
10 Questions
Generated by KedovoAI
Case 1 of 10
Case Study7 marks
The Socratic View of Justice
In his book The Republic, Plato presents a dialogue where Socrates' young friends, Glaucon and Adeimantus, argue that being unjust is often more beneficial. They observe that people who twist rules, evade taxes, and are deceitful often become more successful than those who are just. They propose that if one can be unjust without getting caught, it seems better than being just. Socrates counters this by arguing that if everyone were unjust and manipulated rules for their own benefit, society would become insecure for everyone, and nobody could be sure of benefiting. He clarifies that justice is not merely about pursuing one's own interests or helping friends while harming enemies. For Socrates, justice involves the well-being of all people. A just ruler or government, like a doctor concerned for their patients, must be concerned with the well-being of the people, which includes giving each person their due.
Questions on this case
1(1 mark)MCQ
According to Glaucon, why did being unjust seem better than being just?
2(1 mark)
What is Socrates' main argument for why we should be just?
3(2 marks)
Socrates compares a just ruler to a doctor. What does this analogy imply about the ruler's responsibility?
4(1 mark)MCQ
The Socratic idea of justice involves 'the well-being of all people'. This is different from the idea that justice is...
5(2 marks)
Evaluate the argument that it is in our 'own long-term interest' to be just. Can you think of a situation where this might not seem true?
Case Study7 marks
Principles of Justice in the Workplace
A large corporation is reviewing its salary structure to ensure fairness. It discovers that in some departments, male employees are paid more than female employees for performing the exact same job with similar experience. At the same time, the company has a policy of paying higher salaries and bonuses to employees who take on more dangerous or highly skilled tasks, such as engineers working on remote, high-risk projects, compared to administrative staff in the head office. The review committee is tasked with harmonizing two key principles of justice: ensuring people are not discriminated against based on their group identity and rewarding people differently based on the skill, effort, and risk involved in their work. The goal is to create a system that is both fair and encourages employees to take on challenging roles.
Questions on this case
1(1 mark)MCQ
The practice of paying men more than women for the same job violates which principle of justice?
2(1 mark)
On what grounds does the company justify paying higher salaries to engineers on high-risk projects?
3(2 marks)
Explain the main difference between the principles of 'Equal Treatment for Equals' and 'Proportionate Justice'.
4(1 mark)MCQ
If the company decided to pay every single employee the same salary regardless of their job, it would be ignoring the principle of:
5(2 marks)
How can the company's review committee 'harmonize' these two principles to create a just salary structure?
Case Study7 marks
Reservation and Special Needs
In India, the Constitution allows for reservations of government jobs and quotas for admissions to educational institutions for people belonging to the Scheduled Castes (SC) and Scheduled Tribes (ST). This policy is based on a principle of justice that recognizes the special needs of particular groups. The rationale is that these communities have faced historical social discrimination and lack of access to good education and health care. Therefore, to ensure a just society, it is not enough to simply treat everyone equally in the present. It is believed that if people who have been deprived of basic minimum needs are forced to compete on equal terms with those from privileged backgrounds, the outcome will be an unequal society, not an egalitarian one. This principle of taking account of special needs does not necessarily contradict the principle of equal treatment; rather, it extends it, because treating unequals equally can perpetuate injustice.
Questions on this case
1(1 mark)MCQ
The policy of reservations for SC/ST communities is an application of which principle of justice?
2(1 mark)
What is the primary justification for these reservation policies?
3(2 marks)
Explain the meaning of the statement, 'treating unequals equally can perpetuate injustice'.
4(1 mark)MCQ
How does the principle of special needs 'extend' the principle of equal treatment?
5(2 marks)
Critics of reservation policies argue that they conflict with the principle of merit. Based on the passage, how would a defender of reservations respond to this criticism?