Consumer ProtectionClass 12 Business Studies Part 2 Case Study Questions
10 Questions
Generated by KedovoAI
Case 1 of 10
Case Study7 marks
Deficiency in Banking Services
In a landmark consumer forum judgement in Raipur, a bank was held responsible for the non-availability of cash in its ATMs. A complainant submitted photos and video recordings of three failed ATM transactions. The bank argued that since ATM services rely on internet connectivity, the user is not directly its client at the moment of the transaction, and thus, it cannot be termed a deficiency in service. The consumer forum rejected this argument entirely. It acknowledged that consumers often face the 'cash not available' message, which constitutes a lack of service. The forum ruled that if a bank fails to provide ATM service, it will be considered a deficiency in service. Consequently, the forum imposed a fine of ₹2,500 on the bank, which included ₹1,500 as compensation for mental harassment and ₹1,000 for legal expenses.
Questions on this case
1(1 mark)MCQ
The non-availability of cash in the ATM was considered by the consumer forum as a:
2(1 mark)MCQ
Which consumer right was exercised by the complainant when they filed a petition in the Consumer Forum?
3(1 mark)
What relief was granted to the complainant by the consumer forum?
4(2 marks)
Define 'deficiency' as per the Consumer Protection Act, 2019.
5(2 marks)
Evaluate the bank's argument that an ATM user is not directly its client. Why was it rejected by the forum?
Case Study7 marks
The Case of the Discoloured Jacket
Mrs. Mathur sent a jacket she had purchased for ₹4,500 to 'Shine Dry Cleaners'. Having used their services before with good results, she trusted them. However, this time, upon collecting the jacket, she noticed white discoloration marks. She immediately informed the dry cleaner, who later sent a letter confirming that the discolouration indeed appeared after their cleaning process. Despite multiple requests for compensation, the dry cleaner did not respond positively. Mrs. Mathur, having kept the receipt for the service, decided to approach the consumer court. The court intervened, and the dry cleaner agreed to compensate her with ₹2,500.
Questions on this case
1(1 mark)MCQ
By approaching the consumer court for her grievance, Mrs. Mathur exercised her:
2(1 mark)MCQ
Which consumer responsibility did Mrs. Mathur fulfill that would serve as proof of service availed?
3(1 mark)
Identify and explain the consumer right that ultimately helped Mrs. Mathur receive compensation.
4(2 marks)
The dry cleaner's failure to clean the jacket properly, leading to discolouration, is an example of what shortcoming under the Consumer Protection Act?
5(2 marks)
Which redressal agency should Mrs. Mathur have approached first for her grievance, and why?
Case Study7 marks
The 'Miracle' Slimming Tea
A company, 'SlimFit', launched a massive advertising campaign for its new 'Miracle Tea', claiming it could lead to a 10kg weight loss in just 10 days. The ads featured digitally altered 'before' and 'after' images. Attracted by the claims, Priya bought the product for ₹2,000. After using it for two weeks, she saw no results and instead developed severe stomach problems. A consumer organization, 'Public Aware', sent the tea for lab testing. The results revealed that the tea contained no weight-loss ingredients and had traces of a substance banned for consumption. 'Public Aware' published these findings and helped Priya file a complaint.
Questions on this case
1(1 mark)MCQ
The advertising campaign by 'SlimFit' with false claims and altered images constitutes a(n):
2(1 mark)MCQ
Which consumer right is primarily violated by the misleading advertisement of 'Miracle Tea'?
3(1 mark)
Identify and explain one function performed by the consumer organization 'Public Aware' in this case.
4(2 marks)
Which two consumer rights of Priya were violated by the product itself?
5(2 marks)
Under the Consumer Protection Act 2019, what is the responsibility of 'SlimFit' in this case, and what is this concept called?