ControllingClass 12 Business Studies Part 1 NCERT Solutions
15 Solutions
Generated by KedovoAI
Solution 1 of 15
Q1Long Answer Type
Explain the various steps involved in the process of control.
Solution
Controlling is a systematic process that involves several sequential steps to ensure that organisational activities conform to plans. The steps are as follows:
-
Setting Performance Standards: This is the first step, where standards are established as the criteria against which actual performance will be measured. Standards act as benchmarks and can be set in both quantitative (e.g., units to be produced, revenue to be earned) and qualitative terms (e.g., improving employee motivation). For effective comparison, standards should be precise and flexible enough to be modified if required.
-
Measurement of Actual Performance: Once standards are set, the actual performance is measured in an objective and reliable manner. This can be done through techniques like personal observation, sample checking, or performance reports. Performance should be measured in the same units as the standards to facilitate easy comparison.
-
Comparison of Actual Performance with Standards: This step involves comparing the measured actual performance with the predetermined standards. This comparison reveals any deviation between the desired results and the actual results.
-
Analysing Deviations: Not all deviations require managerial attention. It is important to determine an acceptable range of deviations. Managers use principles like 'Critical Point Control' (focusing on key result areas critical to success) and 'Management by Exception' (addressing only significant deviations) to identify which deviations need urgent attention. After identification, the causes of these deviations, such as unrealistic standards or defective processes, must be analyzed.
-
Taking Corrective Action: This is the final step. If the deviations are within acceptable limits, no action is needed. However, if deviations exceed the acceptable range, immediate managerial action is required to prevent their recurrence. Corrective actions might include training employees, assigning additional resources, or, if the standards are found to be unrealistic, revising the standards themselves.
Q2Long Answer Type
Explain the techniques of managerial control.
Solution
Managerial control techniques can be broadly categorized into traditional and modern techniques, as mentioned in the chapter summary.
Traditional Techniques:
These are the techniques that have been used by organisations for a long time.
- Personal Observation: This involves managers personally observing employees and their work. It provides first-hand information but can be time-consuming and may not be objective.
- Statistical Reports: This technique uses statistical analysis in the form of averages, percentages, ratios, and correlation to present information about performance in various areas. It allows for easy representation and comparison.
- Breakeven Analysis: This is a technique used to study the relationship between costs, volume, and profits. It determines the point at which there is no profit and no loss (the breakeven point), helping managers estimate profits at different levels of activity.
- Budgetary Control: This involves preparing budgets for various operations (e.g., sales budget, production budget) and then comparing the actual results with the budgetary standards. It is a very common technique for planning and control.
Modern Techniques:
These techniques are of recent origin and are better suited to the needs of modern, complex organisations.
- Return on Investment (ROI): This is a useful technique for measuring the overall profitability of an investment. It is calculated as Net Income / Total Investment and helps judge whether the returns are satisfactory.
- Ratio Analysis: This involves analyzing financial statements through the computation of various ratios like liquidity ratios, solvency ratios, and profitability ratios to assess the financial health and performance of the business.
- Responsibility Accounting: In this system, different sections, divisions, and departments are set up as 'responsibility centers'. The head of each center is responsible for achieving the target set for his or her center.
- Management Audit: This refers to a systematic appraisal of the overall performance of the management of an organisation. It reviews the efficiency and effectiveness of management.
- PERT and CPM: Programme Evaluation and Review Technique (PERT) and Critical Path Method (CPM) are network techniques used for planning and controlling complex projects. They help in scheduling and monitoring time-bound projects.
- Management Information System (MIS): This is a computer-based information system that provides accurate and timely information to managers to facilitate decision-making and control.
Q3Long Answer Type
Explain the importance of controlling in an organisation. What are the problems faced by the organisation in implementing an effective control system?
Solution
Controlling is an indispensable function of management that plays a crucial role in organisational success. Its importance can be understood from the following points:
Importance of Controlling:
- Accomplishing Organisational Goals: Controlling measures progress toward goals, highlights deviations, and indicates corrective action, thereby keeping the organisation on the right track.
- Judging Accuracy of Standards: An effective control system helps management verify if the standards set are accurate and objective. It allows for a review and revision of standards based on changes in the business environment.
- Making Efficient Use of Resources: By ensuring each activity is performed according to predetermined standards, controlling helps to reduce the wastage and spoilage of resources.
- Improving Employee Motivation: A good control system informs employees of their performance standards in advance. This clarity motivates them to perform better as they know the basis on which they will be appraised.
- Ensuring Order and Discipline: Controlling creates an atmosphere of order and discipline by keeping a close check on employees' activities, which helps minimize dishonest behavior.
- Facilitating Coordination in Action: It provides direction to all activities, ensuring that different departments and employees work in a coordinated manner towards common organisational objectives.
Problems in Implementing a Control System (Limitations):
Organisations face several problems while implementing a control system:
- Difficulty in Setting Quantitative Standards: Control loses effectiveness when performance standards cannot be set in clear quantitative terms. Areas like employee morale, job satisfaction, and human behavior are difficult to measure.
- Little Control on External Factors: An organisation cannot control external factors like government policies, technological changes, and competition, which can significantly affect its performance regardless of its internal control system.
- Resistance from Employees: Employees often resist control as they may perceive it as a restriction on their freedom. For instance, being monitored by CCTVs can be met with objections.
- Costly Affair: Implementing and operating a control system involves significant expenditure, time, and effort. For a small enterprise, the costs might outweigh the benefits, making it an expensive affair.
Q4Long Answer Type
Discuss the relationship between planning and controlling.
Solution
Planning and controlling are considered the inseparable twins of management, as they are deeply interrelated and interdependent functions. Their relationship can be discussed as follows:
-
Planning provides the basis for Controlling: Planning involves setting objectives and standards of performance. These standards serve as the benchmarks for the controlling function. Without a plan and set standards, managers would have nothing to control, making the controlling function blind.
-
Controlling ensures plans are executed: Once a plan is operational, the controlling function is necessary to monitor progress, measure performance, identify deviations, and take corrective actions. This ensures that events conform to the plans. Thus, planning without controlling is meaningless, as there is no mechanism to ensure its implementation.
-
Planning is Prescriptive, Controlling is Evaluative: Planning is an intellectual process that prescribes an appropriate course of action for achieving objectives. In contrast, controlling is an evaluative function that checks whether decisions have been translated into the desired action and if the outcomes match the plans.
-
Both are Forward-Looking and Backward-Looking: It is often said that planning looks ahead and controlling looks back. While planning is indeed forward-looking as it prepares for the future, it is also guided by past experiences. Similarly, while controlling analyzes past performance, its purpose is to take corrective action to improve future performance. Thus, both functions have forward and backward-looking aspects.
-
They Reinforce Each Other: The management cycle begins with planning and ends with controlling. The controlling function provides valuable information and feedback derived from past experiences, which helps in the formulation of more realistic and effective future plans. In this way, controlling improves future planning, and better planning makes controlling easier and more effective. They are part of a continuous cycle of management.
Q5Long Answer Type
A company 'M' limited is manufacturing mobile phones both for domestic Indian market as well as for export. It had enjoyed a substantial market share and also had a loyal customer following. But lately it has been experiencing problems because its targets have not been met with regard to sales and customer satisfaction. Also mobile market in India has grown tremendously and new players have come with better technology and pricing. This is causing problems for the company. It is planning to revamp its controlling system and take other steps necessary to rectify the problems it is facing. a. Identify the benefits the company will derive from a good control system. b. How can the company relate its planning with control in this line of business to ensure that its plans are actually implemented and targets attained. c. Give the steps in the control process that the company should follow to remove the problems it is facing
Solution
a. Benefits of a good control system for 'M' limited:
A good control system will provide several benefits to the company in its current situation:
- Accomplishing Organisational Goals: It will help the company measure its progress towards its sales and customer satisfaction targets, identify why they are not being met, and take corrective actions to get back on track.
- Judging Accuracy of Standards: The control system will enable management to verify if its sales targets and customer satisfaction standards are realistic and accurate in the face of new competition and technological changes.
- Making Efficient Use of Resources: By exercising control, the company can reduce wastage in production and marketing, ensuring that its resources are used effectively to compete on price and quality.
- Facilitating Coordination in Action: It will help align the efforts of all departments—from R&D and production to marketing and sales—towards the common goal of regaining market share and improving customer satisfaction.
b. Relating Planning with Control:
'M' limited must treat planning and controlling as inseparable functions. The relationship should be established as follows:
- The company's planning process must set clear, specific, and measurable standards. For example, instead of a vague goal, it should set a quantitative sales target (e.g., increase market share by 5% in the next quarter) and define customer satisfaction standards (e.g., reduce customer complaints by 20%).
- The controlling system will then become operational. It will continuously monitor actual sales figures and customer feedback against these planned standards.
- When deviations are found (e.g., sales are still declining), the control process will analyze the causes (e.g., competitor's pricing, lack of a new feature).
- The corrective actions taken (e.g., launching a new model, introducing a promotional offer) are a result of control. This information then becomes crucial feedback for the next planning cycle, helping the company create more realistic and competitive future plans.
c. Steps in the Control Process for 'M' limited:
The company should follow these steps to remove the problems it is facing:
- Setting Performance Standards: The company must set new, realistic standards for sales, market share, and customer satisfaction in both quantitative (e.g., number of units sold) and qualitative (e.g., time taken to resolve customer queries) terms.
- Measurement of Actual Performance: It should regularly measure its actual performance by tracking sales reports, market share data, and conducting customer satisfaction surveys.
- Comparison of Actual Performance with Standards: The company must compare its measured performance against the newly set standards to identify the extent of the deviation.
- Analysing Deviations: It needs to analyze the causes for the deviations. For instance, why are sales targets not being met? Is it due to the competitor's better technology, aggressive pricing, or internal issues like an inefficient sales team? This step is crucial for finding the root cause of the problem.
- Taking Corrective Action: Based on the analysis, the company must take appropriate corrective actions. This might involve investing in new technology, revising its pricing strategy, training its sales force, or improving its after-sales service. If the external market has changed drastically, it may even need to revise its standards.
Q6Long Answer Type
Mr Shantanu is a chief manager of a reputed company that manufactures garments. He called the production manager and instructed him to keep a constant and continuous check on all the activities related to his department so that everything goes as per the set plan. He also suggested him to keep a track of the performance of all the employees in the organisation so that targets are achieved effectively and efficiently. a. Describe any two features of Controlling highlighted in the above situation.(Goal Oriented, continuous and pervasive - any 2 ). b. Explain any four points of importance of Controlling.
Solution
a. The two features of controlling highlighted in the situation are:
- Goal-Oriented Function: Mr. Shantanu instructs the production manager to ensure that 'everything goes as per the set plan' and 'targets are achieved effectively and efficiently'. This shows that the primary purpose of the control being exercised is to ensure that the activities are directed towards the accomplishment of predetermined organisational goals.
- Pervasive Function: Mr. Shantanu, a chief manager, is instructing the production manager to control activities. He also suggests keeping track of the performance of 'all the employees'. This highlights that controlling is a primary function of every manager at all levels (top, middle, and lower) and is required in all areas of an organisation.
b. Four points of importance of Controlling are:
- Accomplishing Organisational Goals: The controlling function measures progress towards organisational goals, identifies any deviations from the plan, and prompts corrective action. This process guides the organisation and keeps it on the right path to achieve its objectives.
- Making Efficient Use of Resources: Through control, a manager seeks to minimize the wastage and spoilage of resources. Since each activity is performed in accordance with predetermined standards and norms, it ensures that resources are used in the most effective and efficient manner possible.
- Improving Employee Motivation: A good control system ensures that employees are well aware of the standards of performance they are expected to meet and on what basis they will be evaluated. This clarity motivates them and helps them to give a better performance.
- Ensuring Order and Discipline: Controlling creates an atmosphere of order and discipline within the organisation. By keeping a close and continuous check on the activities of employees, it helps to minimize dishonest or undesirable behavior and promotes a professional work environment.
Q1Short Answer Type
'Planning is looking ahead and controlling is looking back.' Comment.
Solution
The statement 'Planning is looking ahead and controlling is looking back' is only partially correct. Planning is considered a forward-looking function because it involves preparing for the future based on forecasts. Controlling is considered a backward-looking function because it is like a postmortem of past activities to find deviations from standards.
However, this view is incomplete. Controlling also looks forward because the corrective actions it initiates aim to improve future performance. Similarly, planning is guided by past experiences and the feedback from the control process. Therefore, both planning and controlling are forward-looking as well as backward-looking functions that are deeply interrelated.
Q2Short Answer Type
'An effort to control everything may end up in controlling nothing.' Explain.
Solution
This statement highlights the principle of 'Management by Exception' or 'Control by Exception'. This principle is based on the belief that attempting to control every single activity and deviation in an organisation is impractical and inefficient. Managers have limited time and energy, and if they focus on minor, insignificant deviations, they may miss the major problems that are critical to the organisation's success.
By focusing only on significant deviations that go beyond a permissible limit, managers can use their time more effectively, concentrate on important areas, and avoid getting bogged down in routine issues. This approach also facilitates delegation and increases the morale of subordinates, who are empowered to handle routine problems themselves.
Q3Short Answer Type
Explain how management audit serves as an effective technique of controlling.
Solution
Although the text does not provide a detailed explanation, it lists Management Audit as a modern technique of managerial control. As a control technique, a management audit involves a systematic and comprehensive appraisal of the overall performance of an organisation's management. It reviews the efficiency and effectiveness of management functions, policies, and procedures.
It serves as an effective controlling technique by:
- Measuring Performance: It evaluates how well the management has performed in achieving organisational objectives.
- Analyzing Deviations: It identifies deficiencies, weaknesses, and irregularities in management's performance and decision-making.
- Suggesting Corrective Action: It provides recommendations for improving future managerial performance, thereby helping to ensure that organisational goals are met more effectively and efficiently. It acts as a high-level control that checks the overall health of the management process.
Q4Short Answer Type
Mr.Arfaaz had been heading the production department of Writewell Products Ltd., a firm manufacturing stationary items. The firm secured an export order that had to be completed on a priority basis and production targets were defined for all the employees. One of the workers, Mr.Bhanu Prasad, fell short of his daily production target by 10 units for two days consecutively. Mr.Arfaaz approached MsVasundhara, the CEO of the Company, to file a complaint against MrBhanu Prasad and requested her to terminate his services. Explain the principle of management control that MsVasundhara should consider while taking her decision. (Hint: Management by exception).
Solution
Ms. Vasundhara should consider the principle of 'Management by Exception' before taking a decision. This principle states that managers should focus their attention only on significant deviations from the set standards and not on every minor deviation.
Applying this principle, Ms. Vasundhara should first determine if Mr. Bhanu Prasad's shortfall of 10 units is a 'significant deviation'. An attempt to control everything results in controlling nothing. Instead of taking immediate drastic action like termination, she should:
- Analyze the significance: Is a shortfall of 10 units critical to the completion of the export order? Is there a permissible range of deviation defined for the production targets?
- Investigate the cause: She should ask Mr. Arfaaz to investigate the reasons for the deviation. The cause could be unrealistic standards, a defective process, inadequacy of resources, or personal issues faced by the employee.
- Delegate action: The issue might be a routine problem that should be handled by the production manager, Mr. Arfaaz, through corrective actions like counseling or training, rather than escalating it to the CEO for a termination decision. By doing so, she would be utilizing managerial talent effectively and empowering her subordinates.
Q1Very Short Answer Type
State the meaning of controlling.
Solution
Controlling is an important managerial function that involves ensuring that activities within an organisation are performed according to the plans. It ensures that an organisation's resources are used effectively and efficiently to achieve its predetermined goals, making it a goal-oriented function.
Q2Very Short Answer Type
Name the principle that a manager should consider while dealing with deviations effectively. State any one situation in which an organisation's control system loses its effectiveness.
Solution
A manager should consider the principles of 'Critical Point Control' and 'Management by Exception' while dealing with deviations effectively.
An organisation's control system loses its effectiveness when standards cannot be defined in quantitative terms, such as in the case of measuring employee morale or job satisfaction.
Q3Very Short Answer Type
State any one situation in which an organisation's control system loses is effectiveness.
Solution
An organisation's control system loses effectiveness when it has little or no control over external factors. For example, an enterprise cannot control changes in government policies, technological advancements, or the strategies of its competitors, which can impact its performance despite internal controls.
Q4Very Short Answer Type
Give any two standards that can be used by a company to evaluate the performance of its Finance & Accounting department.
Solution
Based on the standards used in various functional areas, two standards that can be used to evaluate the performance of a Finance & Accounting department are:
- Flow of capital: Monitoring the movement of capital to ensure it is being managed efficiently.
- Liquidity: Assessing the company's ability to meet its short-term obligations.
Q5Very Short Answer Type
Which term is used to indicate the difference between standard performance and actual performance?
Solution
The term used to indicate the difference between standard performance and actual performance is 'deviation'.