Question 1

Q1: What were the ideals expressed in the Objectives Resolution?

Accepted Answer

The Objectives Resolution, introduced by Jawaharlal Nehru in the Constituent Assembly on 13 December 1946, outlined the defining ideals and the guiding principles for framing the Constitution. The key ideals expressed were:    Sovereignty and Republic: It proclaimed India as an "Independent Sovereig...

Question 2

Q2: How was the term minority defined by different groups?

Accepted Answer

The term 'minority' was defined in different ways by various groups within the Constituent Assembly, reflecting their diverse concerns:    Religious Minorities: Some members, like B. Pocker Bahadur from Madras, defined minorities in religious terms. He argued that Muslims were a minority who needed...

Question 3

Q3: What were the arguments in favour of greater power to the provinces?

Accepted Answer

Arguments for granting greater power to the provinces were eloquently put forward by members who feared that an overly centralized constitution would weaken both the states and the Centre itself. The key arguments were:    Effective Governance: K. Santhanam from Madras argued that an overburdened Ce...

Question 4

Q4: Why did Mahatma Gandhi think Hindustani should be the national language?

Accepted Answer

Mahatma Gandhi advocated for Hindustani as the national language for several reasons rooted in his vision of a united and inclusive India:    Language of the Common People: Gandhi believed that the national language should be one that common people could easily speak and understand. Hindustani, bein...

Question 5

Q9: On a present-day political map of India, indicate the different languages spoken in each state and mark out the one that is designated as the language...

Accepted Answer

This is a map-based activity requiring research. The expected findings are outlined below. Comparison of Maps and Key Differences: A political map of India in the early 1950s would show large, multi-lingual provinces and states inherited from the British era, such as:    Bombay State: Comprising are...

Question 6

Q10: Choose any one important constitutional change that has happened in recent years. Find out why the change was made, what different arguments were put...

Accepted Answer

This is a research-based project question. The solution below provides a framework and an example of how to approach it, using the theme of reservation, which is discussed in the chapter. Example Project: The Constitution (103rd Amendment) Act, 2019 - Reservation for Economically Weaker Sections (EW...

Question 7

Q11: Compare the Constitution of America, France or South Africa with the Indian Constitution, focusing on any two of the following themes: secularism, min...

Accepted Answer

This is a research-based project question. The solution below provides a comparative framework using the themes of secularism and centre-state relations between India and the USA, linking them to their respective histories as discussed in the chapter. Comparison: India and the USA 1. Secularism:...

Question 8

Q5: What historical forces shaped the vision of the Constitution?

Accepted Answer

The vision of the Indian Constitution was shaped by a confluence of powerful historical forces, both domestic and international. The tumultuous years preceding its framing left an indelible mark on its principles and structure. First, the experience of colonial rule under the British was a primary s...

Question 9

Q6: Discuss the different arguments made in favour of protection of the oppressed groups.

Accepted Answer

Within the Constituent Assembly, powerful arguments were made for providing constitutional protection and safeguards to India's oppressed groups, though the definition of these groups and the nature of protection varied. For the Depressed Castes, members like J. Nagappa and K.J. Khanderkar articulat...

Question 10

Q7: What connection did some of the members of the Constituent Assembly make between the political situation of the time and the need for a strong Centre?

Accepted Answer

Members of the Constituent Assembly frequently and forcefully connected the turbulent political situation of the time to the urgent need for a strong central government. The context of Partition, communal violence, and the challenge of national integration heavily influenced the arguments for a cent...

Question 11

Q8: How did the Constituent Assembly seek to resolve the language controversy?

Accepted Answer

The Constituent Assembly sought to resolve the deeply divisive language controversy through a carefully crafted compromise formula, arrived at after months of intense and often acrimonious debate. The issue pitted passionate advocates of Hindi as the national language against representatives from no...

NCERT Solutions