The Challenges of Cultural DiversityClass 12 Indian Society Case Study Questions
10 Questions
Generated by KedovoAI
Case 1 of 10
Case Study7 marks
Understanding Ascriptive Identity
Community identity is based on birth and 'belonging' rather than on some form of acquired qualifications or 'accomplishment'. It is what we 'are' rather than what we have 'become'. We don't have to do anything to be born into a community - in fact, no one has any choice about which family or community or country they are born into. These kinds of identities are called 'ascriptive' - that is, they are determined by the birth and do not involve any choice on the part of the individuals concerned. It is an odd fact of social life that people feel a deep sense of security and satisfaction in belonging to communities in which their membership is entirely accidental. We often identify so strongly with communities we have done nothing to 'deserve' - passed no exam, demonstrated no skill or competence... This is very unlike belonging to, say, a profession or team. Doctors or architects have to pass exams and demonstrate their competence. In fact, most ascriptive identities are very hard to shake off; even if we choose to disown them, others may continue to identify us by those very markers of belonging.
Questions on this case
1(1 mark)MCQ
According to the passage, community identity is primarily based on which of the following?
2(1 mark)
What does the term 'ascriptive identity' mean?
3(2 marks)
How does belonging to a community differ from belonging to a profession like a doctor or architect?
4(1 mark)MCQ
Why, according to the passage, can ascriptive identities be very hard to shake off?
5(2 marks)
Evaluate why people might feel a 'deep sense of security and satisfaction' in an identity that is purely 'accidental'.
Case Study7 marks
The Nation-State Relationship
The criterion that comes closest to distinguishing a nation is the state. Unlike the other kinds of communities mentioned before, nations are communities that have a state of their own. That is why the two are joined with a hyphen to form the term nation-state. Generally speaking, in recent times there has been a one-to-one bond between nation and state (one nation, one state; one state, one nation). But this is a new development. It was not true in the past that a single state could represent only one nation, or that every nation must have its own state. For example, when it was in existence, the Soviet Union explicitly recognised that the peoples it governed were of different 'nations'. Similarly, people constituting a nation may actually be citizens or residents of different states. For example, there are more Jamaicans living outside Jamaica than in Jamaica. A different example is provided by 'dual citizenship' laws. In short, today it is hard to define a nation in any way other than to say that it is a community that has succeeded in acquiring a state of its own. Interestingly, the opposite has also become increasingly true. Just as would-be or aspiring nationalities are now more and more likely to work towards forming a state, existing states are also finding it more and more necessary to claim that they represent a nation.
Questions on this case
1(1 mark)MCQ
What term is used when a nation acquires a state of its own?
2(1 mark)
What is the primary criterion that distinguishes a nation from other communities, according to the text?
3(2 marks)
Provide one example from the passage that challenges the 'one nation, one state' model.
4(1 mark)MCQ
According to the passage, what are existing states finding more and more necessary to do?
5(2 marks)
Explain the dual relationship between nations and states in the modern era as described in the passage.
Case Study7 marks
State Policies on Cultural Diversity
Historically, states have tried to establish and enhance their political legitimacy through nation-building strategies. They sought to secure the loyalty and obedience of their citizens through policies of assimilation or integration. Most states feared that the recognition of such difference would lead to social fragmentation and prevent the creation of a harmonious society. In short, such identity politics was considered a threat to state unity.
Policies of assimilation—often involving outright suppression of the identities of ethnic, religious or linguistic groups—try to erode the cultural differences between groups. Policies of integration seek to assert a single national identity by attempting to eliminate ethnonational and cultural differences from the public and political arena, while allowing them in the private domain. Both sets of policies assume a singular national identity.
Assimilationist and integrationist strategies try to establish singular national identities through various interventions like imposing a unified legal system, adopting the dominant group's language as the only official 'national' language, and promoting the dominant group's culture through state-controlled media and educational institutions.
Questions on this case
1(1 mark)MCQ
According to the passage, why have most states historically feared cultural diversity?
2(1 mark)
What is the primary goal of assimilationist policies?
3(2 marks)
How do integrationist policies differ from assimilationist policies regarding the private domain?
4(1 mark)MCQ
Which of the following is an example of an assimilationist or integrationist strategy mentioned in the text?
5(2 marks)
Both assimilationist and integrationist policies share a common assumption. What is it, and why might it be problematic in a diverse country?