Politics of Planned DevelopmentClass 12 Politics in India Since Independence Case Study Questions
10 Questions
Generated by KedovoAI
Case 1 of 10
Case Study7 marks
The Development Dilemma in Orissa
As the global demand for steel increases, Orissa, which has one of the largest reserves of untapped iron ore in the country, is being seen as an important investment destination. The State government hopes to cash in on this unprecedented demand for iron ore and has signed Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) with both international and domestic steel makers. The government believes that this would bring in necessary capital investment and provide a lot of employment opportunities. The iron ore resources lie in some of the most underdeveloped and predominantly tribal districts of the state. The tribal population fears that the setting up of industries would mean displacement from their home and livelihood. The environmentalists fear that mining and industry would pollute the environment. The central government feels that if the industry is not allowed it would set a bad example and discourage investments in the country.
Questions on this case
1(1 mark)MCQ
What is the primary resource that makes Orissa an important investment destination according to the passage?
2(1 mark)
What is the main fear of the tribal population regarding the proposed industrial projects?
3(1 mark)MCQ
Which of these groups is NOT explicitly mentioned as a stakeholder in the Orissa conflict?
4(2 marks)
What is the central government's primary concern if the industry is not allowed to be set up?
5(2 marks)
Explain how this case illustrates that 'development' can have different meanings for different groups of people.
Case Study7 marks
Models of Development after Independence
On the eve of Independence, India had before it, two models of modern development: the liberal-capitalist model as in much of Europe and the US and the socialist model as in the USSR. You have already studied these two ideologies and read about the 'cold war' between the two super powers. There were many in India then who were deeply impressed by the Soviet model of development. These included not just the leaders of the Communist Party of India, but also those of the Socialist Party and leaders like Nehru within the Congress. There were very few supporters of the American style capitalist development. This reflected a broad consensus that had developed during the national movement. The nationalist leaders were clear that the economic concerns of the government of free India would have to be different from the narrowly defined commercial functions of the colonial government. It was clear, moreover, that the task of poverty alleviation and social and economic redistribution was being seen primarily as the responsibility of the government.
Questions on this case
1(1 mark)MCQ
Which of the two models of modern development had more supporters in post-independence India?
2(1 mark)
Name the two models of development that India could choose from after independence.
3(1 mark)MCQ
Leaders like Nehru were impressed by which country's model of development?
4(2 marks)
Why did nationalist leaders feel that the government of free India needed a different economic approach from the colonial government?
5(2 marks)
What was the 'broad consensus' that developed during the national movement regarding the economy of independent India?
Case Study7 marks
The Bombay Plan
Despite the various differences, there was a consensus on one point: that development could not be left to private actors, that there was the need for the government to develop a design or plan for development. In fact the idea of planning as a process of rebuilding economy earned a good deal of public support in the 1940s and 1950s all over the world. We commonly assume that private investors, such as industrialists and big business entrepreneurs, are averse to ideas of planning: they seek an open economy without any state control in the flow of capital. That was not what happened here. Rather, a section of the big industrialists got together in 1944 and drafted a joint proposal for setting up a planned economy in the country. It was called the Bombay Plan. The Bombay Plan wanted the state to take major initiatives in industrial and other economic investments. Thus, from left to right, planning for development was the most obvious choice for the country after Independence.
Questions on this case
1(1 mark)MCQ
What was the name of the joint proposal drafted by industrialists in 1944 for a planned economy?
2(1 mark)
Who drafted the Bombay Plan?
3(1 mark)MCQ
The Bombay Plan advocated for the state to do what?
4(2 marks)
Why was the creation of the Bombay Plan by industrialists considered unusual?
5(2 marks)
How did the Bombay Plan contribute to the post-independence consensus on economic policy?