Therapeutic ApproachesClass 12 Psychology Notes

Nature and Process of Psychotherapy

Psychotherapy is a voluntary relationship between a person seeking help (the client) and a trained professional who provides that help (the therapist). The main goal is to help the client solve psychological problems. This is done by building a trusting relationship where the client can freely discuss their issues.

Psychotherapy aims to:

• Change maladaptive behaviours (behaviours that prevent a person from adapting to situations).
• Decrease personal distress.
• Help the client adapt better to their environment.

Characteristics of Psychotherapy

All psychotherapeutic approaches share some common features:

• They systematically apply principles from different theories of therapy.
• Only individuals with practical training under expert supervision can practice psychotherapy. An untrained person could cause more harm than good.
• The process involves a therapist and a client, with the client being the focus of attention.
• The interaction between the therapist and client forms a therapeutic relationship, which is confidential, interpersonal, and dynamic. This relationship is the key vehicle for change.

Goals of Psychotherapy

The goals of psychotherapy can include:

• Reinforcing the client's resolve to get better.
• Lessening emotional pressure.
• Unfolding the client's potential for positive growth.
• Modifying habits and changing thinking patterns.
• Increasing self-awareness and improving interpersonal relations.
• Facilitating decision-making.
• Helping the client become aware of their choices in life.
• Enabling the client to relate to their social environment more creatively.

Therapeutic Relationship

The special bond between a client and a therapist is called the therapeutic relationship or therapeutic alliance. It is not a casual friendship, nor is it a permanent relationship.

It has two main components:

1. Contractual Nature: The client and therapist willingly enter a partnership to help the client overcome their problems.
2. Limited Duration: The alliance lasts until the client is able to manage their problems and take control of their life.

Unique Properties of the Therapeutic Relationship

• Trusting and Confiding: A high level of trust allows the client to open up about their personal problems. The therapist encourages this by being accepting, genuine, and warm.
• Unconditional Positive Regard: The therapist shows positive feelings towards the client, regardless of what the client says or does. The therapist does not judge the client.
• Empathy: The therapist is able to understand the client's situation from their perspective—essentially "putting oneself in the other person's shoes." This is different from sympathy (feeling pity) or intellectual understanding (a cold, detached understanding). Empathy turns the therapeutic relationship into a healing one.
• Confidentiality: The therapist must keep everything the client discloses strictly confidential.
• Professionalism: The relationship is professional and must remain so. The therapist must not exploit the client's trust.

Type of Therapies

While all therapies aim to reduce human distress, they differ in their concepts and methods. They can be broadly classified into three groups: psychodynamic, behaviour, and existential psychotherapies.

These therapies can be compared based on the following parameters:

What is the cause of the problem?

• Psychodynamic Therapy: Intrapsychic conflicts (conflicts within the person's mind) are the source of problems.
• Behaviour Therapy: Faulty learning of behaviours and thoughts causes psychological problems.
• Existential Therapy: Problems arise from questions about the meaning of one's life and existence.

How did the cause come into existence?

• Psychodynamic Therapy: Unfulfilled childhood desires and unresolved childhood fears lead to these conflicts.
• Behaviour Therapy: Faulty conditioning, learning, and beliefs lead to maladaptive behaviours.
• Existential Therapy: The focus is on the present. Current feelings of loneliness, alienation, and a sense of futility cause problems.

What is the chief method of treatment?

• Psychodynamic Therapy: Uses methods like free association and dream reporting. The therapist interprets this material to help the client resolve their conflicts.
• Behaviour Therapy: Identifies faulty conditioning and thinking patterns and sets up new ways to improve behaviour.
• Existential Therapy: Provides a positive, accepting, and non-judgmental environment. The therapist acts as a facilitator, and the client finds solutions through personal growth.

What is the nature of the therapeutic relationship?

• Psychodynamic & Behaviour Therapy: The therapist is seen as the expert who understands the client's problems and can find solutions. The relationship is more directive.
• Existential Therapy: The therapist provides a warm, empathic relationship where the client feels secure enough to explore their problems on their own. The relationship is non-directive.

What is the chief benefit to the client?

• Psychodynamic Therapy: The client gains emotional insight—an intellectual and emotional understanding and acceptance of their conflicts, which reduces symptoms.
• Behaviour Therapy: The chief benefit is changing faulty behaviour and thought patterns to adaptive ones.
• Humanistic Therapy: The main benefit is personal growth, which involves gaining a deeper understanding of oneself, one's aspirations, emotions, and motives.

What is the duration of treatment?

• Psychodynamic Therapy: Classical psychoanalysis can last for several years, though modern versions may be completed in 10-15 sessions.
• Behaviour, Cognitive & Existential Therapies: These are typically shorter and completed within a few months.

Steps in the Formulation of a Client's Problem

Clinical formulation means describing the client's problem using the model of the therapy being used. This is a crucial first step and is usually done after the first one or two sessions.

This formulation has several advantages:

1. Understanding the problem: The therapist gains a full understanding of the client's distress.
2. Identification of target areas: It clearly identifies which problems need to be addressed in therapy.
3. Choice of techniques for treatment: The formulation helps the therapist choose the right techniques and predict the outcome of the therapy.

Behaviour Therapy

Behaviour therapies operate on the principle that psychological distress is caused by faulty behaviour or thought patterns. The focus is on the client's present behaviour and thoughts, not on reliving the past.

The therapy consists of a large set of specific techniques based on learning theories. The choice of technique depends on the client's symptoms and diagnosis. The foundation of this therapy is to identify dysfunctional behaviours, understand what reinforces them, and then devise methods to change them.

Method of Treatment

The therapist conducts a behavioural analysis to identify:

• Malfunctioning behaviours: Behaviours that cause distress to the client.
• Antecedent factors: The causes that predispose the person to that behaviour.
• Maintaining factors: The factors that lead to the persistence of the faulty behaviour.

• Malfunctioning Behaviour: Smoking.
• Antecedent Factor: The anxiety-provoking situation of preparing for an exam.
• Maintaining Factor: The feeling of relief from anxiety after smoking. The relief reinforces the smoking behaviour.

Once these factors are identified, the therapist chooses a treatment package to eliminate faulty behaviours and replace them with adaptive ones. This is done by establishing antecedent operations (changing something that precedes the behaviour) and consequent operations (praising or rewarding the desired behaviour).

Behavioural Techniques

• Negative Reinforcement and Aversive Conditioning: Negative reinforcement involves learning to avoid or escape painful stimuli. Aversive conditioning repeatedly pairs an undesired response (like drinking alcohol) with an aversive consequence (like a mild electric shock) until the response itself becomes aversive.
• Positive Reinforcement: If a desired behaviour occurs rarely, it is rewarded to increase its frequency. This is the principle behind a token economy, where a person receives tokens for good behaviour, which can be exchanged for a reward.
• Differential Reinforcement: This technique increases a wanted behaviour while reducing an unwanted one. One method is to positively reinforce the wanted behaviour and ignore the unwanted one.

• Systematic Desensitisation: A technique introduced by Wolpe for treating phobias. It works on the principle of reciprocal inhibition, which states that two opposing forces (like anxiety and relaxation) cannot exist at the same time; the stronger one will inhibit the weaker one.
  1. The therapist and client create a hierarchy of anxiety-provoking situations, from least to most fearful.
  2. The therapist teaches the client relaxation techniques.
  3. The client, in a relaxed state, imagines the least anxiety-provoking situation. If any tension is felt, they stop.
  4. Over several sessions, the client learns to imagine more severe situations while staying relaxed, thus becoming desensitised to the fear.
• Modelling: The client learns to behave in a certain way by observing a role model (often the therapist). This is a form of vicarious learning (learning by observing others).

Cognitive Therapy

Cognitive therapies propose that irrational thoughts and beliefs are the cause of psychological distress.

Rational Emotive Therapy (RET)

Developed by Albert Ellis, the central idea of RET is that irrational beliefs mediate between an event and its emotional consequence.

1. ABC Analysis: The therapist and client perform an Antecedent-Belief-Consequence (ABC) analysis. The Antecedent event is identified, followed by the irrational Beliefs about the event, and finally the emotional Consequence.
2. Refuting Beliefs: Irrational beliefs are often characterised by "musts" and "shoulds" (e.g., "One should be loved by everybody all the time"). The therapist refutes these beliefs through gentle, non-directive questioning, helping the client see how they are not supported by reality.
3. Changing Philosophy: Gradually, the client changes their irrational beliefs to a more rational belief system, which reduces their psychological distress.

Aaron Beck's Cognitive Therapy

Aaron Beck's theory suggests that childhood experiences can lead to the development of core schemas or belief systems.

• A critical incident in a person's life can trigger a core schema, leading to negative automatic thoughts (persistent irrational thoughts like "nobody loves me").
• These thoughts are characterised by cognitive distortions—ways of thinking that distort reality in a negative way.
• The therapist uses gentle, non-threatening questioning to help the client challenge these negative thoughts and gain insight into their dysfunctional schemas. The goal is cognitive restructuring, which reduces anxiety and depression.

Cognitive Behaviour Therapy (CBT)

Currently the most popular therapy, Cognitive Behaviour Therapy (CBT) is a short and effective treatment for a wide range of disorders like anxiety, depression, and panic attacks.

CBT adopts a bio-psychosocial approach, understanding that a client's distress has biological, psychological, and social origins. It combines cognitive therapy with behavioural techniques, making it a comprehensive approach that addresses all aspects of a client's problem.

Humanistic-existential Therapy

This group of therapies suggests that psychological distress comes from feelings of loneliness, alienation, and an inability to find meaning in life. The core belief is that humans are motivated by a desire for personal growth and self-actualisation—an innate force that moves a person to become more complex, balanced, and integrated. When this need is blocked by society or family, distress occurs.

Healing happens when the client can identify and remove these obstacles. The therapist acts as a facilitator, while the client takes responsibility for their own growth.

Existential Therapy

Victor Frankl proposed Logotherapy, which means "treatment for the soul." He believed that the search for meaning is a primary human drive.

• Frankl called the process of finding meaning, even in terrible circumstances, meaning making.
• He proposed a spiritual unconscious that stores love, aesthetic awareness, and life values.
• Existential anxiety arises when life's problems are connected to the spiritual aspect of one's existence, leading to a sense of meaninglessness.
• The goal of logotherapy is to help patients find meaning and responsibility in their lives. The therapist is open and focuses on the "here and now."

Client-centred Therapy

Developed by Carl Rogers, this therapy focuses on the concept of the self, with freedom and choice at its core.

• The therapy provides a warm relationship where the client can reconnect with their disintegrated feelings.
• The therapist shows empathy, warmth, and unconditional positive regard (total acceptance of the client as they are).
• This secure environment allows the client to explore their feelings freely.
• The therapist reflects the client's feelings in a non-judgmental way, often by rephrasing their statements to enhance meaning. This process helps the client become more integrated and achieve their "real self."

Gestalt Therapy

Developed by Fritz Perls, this therapy aims to increase an individual's self-awareness and self-acceptance. The German word gestalt means "whole."

• The client is taught to recognize bodily processes and emotions that are being blocked from awareness.
• The therapist encourages the client to act out fantasies about feelings and conflicts to achieve this awareness.

Factors Contributing to Healing in Psychotherapy

Several factors contribute to the healing process in psychotherapy:

1. Therapeutic Techniques: The specific techniques used by the therapist, such as relaxation procedures in behaviour therapy or cognitive restructuring in CBT, are a major factor.
2. Therapeutic Alliance: The relationship itself has healing properties due to the therapist's regular availability, warmth, and empathy.
3. Catharsis: In the initial sessions, the client unburdens their emotional problems. This process of emotional unburdening, known as catharsis, has healing properties.
4. Non-specific Factors: These are factors that occur across different therapies and are not specific to any one approach.
   • Patient variables: Motivation for change and expectation of improvement.
   • Therapist variables: A positive nature, good mental health, and the absence of unresolved emotional conflicts.

Ethics in Psychotherapy

Professional psychotherapists must adhere to strict ethical standards:

• Informed consent must be obtained.
• Confidentiality of the client must be maintained.
• The primary goal must be to alleviate personal distress and suffering.
• The integrity of the practitioner-client relationship is crucial.
• There must be respect for human rights and dignity.
• The therapist must have professional competence and skills.

Alternative Therapies

Alternative therapies are treatment options outside of conventional drug treatment or psychotherapy. Examples include yoga, meditation, acupuncture, and herbal remedies.

Yoga and Meditation

• Yoga is an ancient Indian technique involving asanas (body postures) and pranayama (breathing practices).
• Meditation is the practice of focusing attention on the breath, an object, or a thought.
• Vipasana meditation (mindfulness-based meditation) involves passively observing bodily sensations and thoughts without a fixed object of attention.

Benefits of Alternative Therapies

• Sudarshana Kriya Yoga (SKY), a rapid breathing technique, is beneficial for treating stress, anxiety, PTSD, and depression.
• Research at NIMHANS, India, has shown that SKY reduces depression and stress levels in alcoholic patients.
• Kundalini Yoga, which combines breathing techniques with chanting mantras, has been found effective in treating obsessive-compulsive disorder.
• Mindfulness-based meditation can help prevent repeated episodes of depression by helping patients process emotional stimuli better.

Rehabilitation of the Mentally Ill

The treatment of psychological disorders has two components: reducing symptoms and improving the level of functioning or quality of life. For severe mental disorders like schizophrenia, simply reducing symptoms may not be enough.

Rehabilitation is required to help such patients become self-sufficient and productive members of society. This involves:

• Occupational Therapy: Patients are taught skills like candle making or weaving to help them form a work discipline.
• Social Skills Training: Through role play and imitation, patients develop interpersonal skills to function in a social group.
• Cognitive Retraining: This helps improve basic cognitive functions like attention, memory, and executive functions.
• Vocational Training: Once a patient improves, they are given training to gain skills for productive employment.