ElectionsClass 9 Social Science Case Study Questions

10 Questions
Generated by KedovoAI
Case 1 of 10
Case Study6 marks

Comparing Electoral Systems

The first step towards successfully conducting elections is deciding on the method of converting votes into seats. The way an electoral system allocates seats is what distinguishes it from other systems. The table below compares three imaginary countries and their electoral systems.
FeatureFirst Past The Post (FPTP)Majority SystemProportional Representation (PR)
Name of the CountryHaritbhumiRatnadweepSwarnalok
Seats in the Parliament25 seats25 seats100 seats (nationwide list)
How Voting Works?Each voter votes for one candidate in their constituency. The candidate with the most votes wins, even if the votes are less than 50% of total votes polled.Each voter votes for one candidate. To win, a candidate must receive more than 50% of the votes. If not, the top two candidates compete again in the second round.Voters vote for a party, not a person. Seats in the Parliament are allotted in proportion to the total votes received by each party.
Sample Results (Vote %)Party A: 40%Party X: 45%, Party Y: 40%, Party Z: 15%Party M: 40%, Party N: 35%, Party O: 15%, Party P: 10%
Who forms the Government?Party A forms the government.No one got 50% in Round 1. In Round 2, Party Y wins with 55%, and forms the government.Seats distributed: M: 40; N: 35; O: 15; P: 10. Power is shared proportionately.
Questions on this case
1
In which country does a candidate need more than 50% of the votes to win in the first round?
(1 mark)MCQ
2
What is the key difference between how a voter casts their vote in Swarnalok compared to Haritbhumi?
(1 mark)
3
In Haritbhumi, Party A forms the government with only 40% of the votes. What feature of the FPTP system allows this to happen?
(1 mark)
4
In Swarnalok, how many seats in parliament would Party P receive?
(1 mark)MCQ
5
Based on the table, evaluate which system, FPTP or PR, better reflects the overall vote share of all parties in the final seat allocation. Justify your answer.
(2 marks)