Towards ModernisationClass 11 History Case Study Questions
9 Questions
Generated by KedovoAI
Case 1 of 9
Case Study7 marks
Competing Models of Industrialisation
Britain has been the world's first industrial nation. For long it was believed that British industrialisation provided the model for industrialisation in other countries. However, historians have begun to question some of the earlier ideas about the Industrial Revolution. Each country drew upon the experiences of other nations, without necessarily reproducing any model. In Britain, for instance, coal and cotton textile industries were developed in the first phase of industrialisation, while the invention of railways initiated the second stage of that process. In other countries such as Russia, which began to industrialise much later (from the late nineteenth century onwards), the railway and other heavy industry emerged in the initial phase of industrialisation itself. Likewise, the role of the state, and of banks, in industrialisation has differed from country to country. The British case, no doubt, influenced the industrial trajectories of other nations such as the USA and Germany, two significant industrial powers.
Questions on this case
1(1 mark)MCQ
Which country is considered the world's first industrial nation?
2(1 mark)
According to the passage, what industries developed in the first phase of British industrialisation?
3(1 mark)MCQ
How did the initial phase of industrialisation in Russia differ from that in Britain?
4(2 marks)
What modern historical view on the Industrial Revolution does the passage highlight?
5(2 marks)
Analyse the argument that the British Industrial Revolution was not a universal 'model'.
Case Study7 marks
Competing Notions of Civilisation
European powers began to colonise parts of America and Asia and South Africa well before the Industrial Revolution. Theme 6 tells you the story of what European settlers did to the native peoples of America and Australia. The bourgeois mentality of the settlers made them buy and sell everything, including land and water. But the natives, who appeared uncivilised to European Americans, asked, 'If you do not own the freshness of the air and the sparkle of the water, how can one buy them?' The natives did not feel the need to own land, fish or animals. They had no desire to commodify them; if things needed to be exchanged, they could simply be gifted. Quite obviously, the natives and the Europeans represented competing notions of civilisation. The former did not allow the European deluge to wipe out their cultures although the US and Canadian governments of the mid-twentieth century desired natives to 'join the mainstream'.
Questions on this case
1(1 mark)MCQ
What does the passage describe as the 'bourgeois mentality' of the settlers?
2(1 mark)
How did the natives view the exchange of things?
3(1 mark)
What fundamental question did the natives ask that highlighted their different worldview?
4(2 marks)MCQ
The term 'mainstream' in the context of US and Canadian governments' desires implied that natives should:
5(2 marks)
Explain the 'competing notions of civilisation' mentioned in the passage, using the examples of land and exchange.
Case Study7 marks
Mutual Perceptions
In the eighteenth century, western Europeans defined 'civilised' people in terms of literacy, an organised religion and urbanism. To them, the natives of America appeared 'uncivilised'. To some, like the French philosopher Jean-Jacques Rousseau, such people were to be admired, as they were untouched by the corruptions of 'civilisation'. A popular term was 'the noble savage'. Some lines in a poem by the English poet William Wordsworth indicate another perspective. He described them as living 'amid wilds/Where fancy hath small liberty to grace/The affections, to exalt them or refine', meaning that people living close to nature had only limited powers of imagination and emotion! It is interesting to note that another writer, Washington Irving, who had actually met native people, described them quite differently, noting their wit and distrust of white men, and how they entertained themselves at the expense of the whites.
Questions on this case
1(1 mark)MCQ
According to the passage, who popularised the term 'the noble savage'?
2(1 mark)
What were the three criteria western Europeans used to define 'civilised' people?
3(1 mark)
How did William Wordsworth perceive the native peoples?
4(2 marks)MCQ
Why was Washington Irving's description of native people different from Wordsworth's?
5(2 marks)
Evaluate how the European perceptions of natives, whether as 'noble savages' or 'uncivilised', were based on European standards rather than reality.