Local GovernmentsClass 11 India Constitution At Work Case Study Questions
10 Questions
Generated by KedovoAI
Case 1 of 10
Case Study7 marks
The Impact of a Pro-active Sarpanch
Geeta Rathore belongs to Jamonia Talab Gram Panchayat, Sehore district, Madhya Pradesh. She was elected Sarpanch in 1995 from a reserved seat; but in 2000, the village people rewarded her for her admirable work by electing her again - this time from a non-reserved seat. From a housewife, Geeta has grown into a leader displaying political farsightedness - she has harnessed the collective energy of her Panchayat to renovate water tanks, build a school building, construct village roads, fight against domestic violence and atrocities against women, create environmental awareness, and encourage afforestation and water management in her village. Her story is representative of a larger transformation that is taking place across India especially after constitutional status was accorded to local government institutions in 1993.
Questions on this case
1(1 mark)MCQ
From which type of seat was Geeta Rathore first elected as Sarpanch in 1995?
2(1 mark)
List any two developmental works undertaken by Geeta Rathore in her village.
3(2 marks)
Why was Geeta Rathore's re-election in 2000 from a non-reserved seat significant?
4(1 mark)MCQ
The passage suggests Geeta's story is part of a 'larger transformation'. This transformation was spurred by which major event?
5(2 marks)
How does Geeta Rathore's proactive role demonstrate the importance of local government in strengthening democracy?
Case Study7 marks
Panchayat vs. State Authority
She was the President (Sarpanch) of a Gram Panchayat of Vengaivasal village in Tamil Nadu. In 1997, the Tamil Nadu government allotted two hectares of land to 71 government employees. This piece of land fell within the vicinity of this Gram Panchayat. On the instructions of higher authorities the District Collector of Kancheepuram directed the President of the Gram Panchayat to pass a resolution endorsing the allotment. The President and the Gram Panchayat refused. The Collector then issued an order to acquire the land. The Gram Panchayat filed a writ petition in the Madras High Court. The single judge bench upheld the Collector's order. The Panchayat appealed to the Division bench, which reversed the order of the single judge. The judges held that the government order amounted to not only infringement of the powers of the Panchayats but a gross violation of the constitutional status of the Panchayats.
Questions on this case
1(1 mark)MCQ
What did the District Collector direct the Gram Panchayat President to do?
2(1 mark)
What was the initial outcome of the Gram Panchayat's writ petition in the Madras High Court?
3(2 marks)
On what grounds did the Division Bench of the High Court rule in favour of the Gram Panchayat?
4(1 mark)MCQ
This case study is an example of a local government's mission to ensure what key democratic principle?
5(2 marks)
Explain how the final verdict in the Vengaivasal case reinforces the idea of decentralisation introduced by the 73rd Amendment.
Case Study6 marks
Constitutional Debates on Local Government
When the Constitution was prepared, the subject of local government was assigned to the States and mentioned in the Directive Principles, making it non-justiciable and advisory. It is felt that the subject did not receive adequate importance. A few reasons can be advanced. Firstly, the turmoil due to the Partition resulted in a strong unitary inclination in the Constitution. Nehru himself looked upon extreme localism as a threat to unity and integration of the nation. Secondly, there was a powerful voice in the Constituent Assembly led by Dr. B.R. Ambedkar which felt that the faction and caste-ridden nature of rural society would defeat the noble purpose of local government at the rural level. However, nobody denied the importance of people's participation in development planning. Many members wanted Village Panchayats to be the basis of democracy in India but were concerned about the ills present in the villages.
Questions on this case
1(1 mark)MCQ
In the original Constitution, the provision for local government was placed in which part, making it non-justiciable?
2(1 mark)
What was Dr. B.R. Ambedkar's primary concern about establishing strong local governments in rural India?
3(1 mark)
According to the passage, what was Nehru's view on 'extreme localism'?
4(1 mark)MCQ
The 'strong unitary inclination' in the Constitution was a result of what major historical event?
5(2 marks)
Though both Nehru and Ambedkar had reservations about strong local governments, were their reasons identical? Explain the difference in their concerns.