Patterns of Social Inequality and ExclusionClass 12 Indian Society NCERT Solutions
11 Solutions
Generated by KedovoAI
Solution 1 of 11
Q3QUESTIONS
How would you distinguish prejudice from other kinds of opinion or belief?
Solution
Prejudice can be distinguished from other kinds of opinions or beliefs based on the following characteristics mentioned in the chapter:
- Pre-conceived Nature: Prejudice literally means 'pre-judgement'. It is an opinion or attitude formed in advance of any real familiarity with the subject, without considering available evidence. Other opinions are often formed after gathering and evaluating information.
- Basis in Hearsay: Prejudiced views are often based on hearsay or stereotypes rather than direct evidence or experience. A stereotype is a fixed and inflexible characterisation of a group of people, which ignores individual variations.
- Resistance to Change: Prejudice is highly resistant to change, even when presented with new information or contradictory evidence. A prejudiced person holds onto their preconceived notions, whereas other beliefs might be revised when new facts emerge.
- Application to Groups: Prejudice is typically held by members of one group towards another. It involves applying fixed characteristics (stereotypes) to an entire group, such as an ethnic or racial community, treating them as a single, homogenous entity.
Still unsure?
Q5QUESTIONS
What is the relationship between caste and economic inequality today?
Solution
The relationship between caste and economic inequality today is complex. While the rigid link between caste and occupation has weakened, a strong correlation between caste status and economic status persists at a macro level.
- Weakening of Rigid Links: In modern times, it is easier than before for individuals to change their occupation, and ritual-religious prohibitions on occupational change are not easily imposed. Consequently, rich and poor people can be found in every caste.
- Persistence at the Macro Level: Despite these changes, the overall correlation between caste and class remains remarkably stable. The privileged and high-economic-status sections of society are still overwhelmingly dominated by the 'upper' castes. Conversely, the disadvantaged and low-economic-status sections are predominantly composed of the so-called 'lower' castes (Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes, and Other Backward Classes).
- Data-backed Correlation: As shown in Tables 1 and 2 in the chapter, the proportion of the population living in poverty is much higher for STs and SCs compared to the national average. Similarly, the percentage of the population that is affluent is significantly higher among upper-caste Hindus, Sikhs, and Christians compared to STs, SCs, and OBCs. This data demonstrates that caste continues to significantly affect the economic life chances of Indians.
Still unsure?
Q6QUESTIONS
What is untouchability?
Solution
Untouchability is an extreme and particularly vicious aspect of the caste system that imposes severe social sanctions on members of castes located at the bottom of the purity-pollution hierarchy. The key dimensions of untouchability are:
- Exclusion: It involves extreme forms of social exclusion that are not practiced against other groups. This includes being prohibited from sharing drinking water sources, participating in collective religious worship and festivals, and in some regions, even having one's shadow or presence considered polluting ('distance pollution').
- Humiliation-Subordination: Members of 'untouchable' castes are subjected to constant acts of subordination and public humiliation. The names used to refer to these castes were derogatory, and their use is now a criminal offense.
- Exploitation: Untouchability is almost always associated with economic exploitation. This often takes the form of forced, unpaid, or under-paid labour (begar) or the confiscation of property.
It is a pan-Indian phenomenon, though its specific forms and intensity vary across regions. The term 'Dalit', meaning 'downtrodden', is now the preferred term used by these communities to assert their identity and struggle for rights.
Still unsure?
Q7QUESTIONS
Describe some of the policies designed to address caste inequality.
Solution
The Indian state has implemented several policies to address caste inequality and discrimination, both before and after Independence. Some of the most significant initiatives include:
-
Reservations: This is the most important state initiative. It involves setting aside a proportion of seats for members of Scheduled Castes (SCs), Scheduled Tribes (STs), and Other Backward Classes (OBCs) in:
- State and Central legislatures (Lok Sabha, Rajya Sabha, State Assemblies).
- Government jobs and public sector companies.
- Educational institutions, including higher education. The proportion of reserved seats for SCs and STs is based on their percentage share in the population.
-
Legislation: A number of laws have been passed to prohibit and punish caste discrimination.
- The Constitution of India (1950): Article 17 formally abolished untouchability.
- Caste Disabilities Removal Act (1850): This early law disallowed the curtailment of citizens' rights due to a change of religion or caste and was used to allow Dalit entry into government schools.
- Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act (1989): This act strengthened the legal provisions to punish acts of violence, discrimination, and humiliation against Dalits and Adivasis.
- Constitution (93rd Amendment) Act, 2005: This introduced reservations for OBCs in institutions of higher education.
These state actions are complemented by the political, social, and cultural movements led by Dalits themselves to struggle for justice and dignity.
Still unsure?
Q8QUESTIONS
How are the Other Backward Classes different from the Dalits (or Scheduled Castes)?
Solution
The Other Backward Classes (OBCs) are different from the Dalits (Scheduled Castes) in several important ways:
-
Position in Caste Hierarchy: Dalits, or the ex-untouchables, were historically considered outside the caste hierarchy altogether, at the very bottom of the purity-pollution scale. In contrast, the OBCs were part of the caste hierarchy, occupying the lower rungs as service and artisanal castes. They were considered 'shudra' varnas.
-
Experience of Discrimination: Dalits were subjected to the extreme and vicious practice of untouchability, which involved severe forms of exclusion, humiliation, and exploitation. While OBCs also faced discrimination and were of low status, they were not subjected to untouchability.
-
Diversity: The OBC category is much more diverse than the Dalits. It includes a wide range of castes with varying socio-economic conditions. There are 'upper' OBCs, who are often landed castes with significant local power, and 'lower' OBCs, whose socio-economic condition is often not very different from that of the Dalits.
-
Constitutional Category: The Constitution identifies OBCs as 'socially and educationally backward classes', a category distinct from the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes. They are defined negatively as those who are neither 'forward' castes nor Dalits.
Still unsure?
Q9QUESTIONS
What are the major issues of concern to adivasis today?
Solution
The major issues of concern to Adivasis (tribal communities) today stem from a long history of exploitation and displacement that began in the colonial era and has continued in independent India.
-
Loss of Forests and Livelihoods: The colonial government reserved most forest tracts, severing the rights of Adivasis to use the forest for their livelihood (gathering produce, shifting cultivation). This policy continued after Independence, denying them access to their primary resource base and making their lives poorer and more insecure.
-
Displacement due to 'Development' Projects: Adivasi lands are rich in mineral resources and ideal for power generation projects. In the name of 'national development', their lands have been rapidly acquired for mining, industrial projects, and the construction of large dams (like the Sardar Sarovar and Polavaram dams). This has led to the displacement of millions of Adivasis, often without proper compensation or rehabilitation.
-
Internal Colonialism and Alienation: The policies of capital-intensive industrialization and resource extraction have been a form of internal colonialism, subjugating Adivasis and alienating them from the resources upon which they depend. The benefits of 'development' in their lands have largely gone to non-tribal populations, while Adivasis have borne the costs.
-
Intrusion by Outsiders: The movement of non-tribals, moneylenders, and corporate firms into tribal areas has led to the loss of their land and culture. The term 'Adivasi' itself connotes a political awareness and assertion of rights against these intrusions.
Still unsure?
Q10QUESTIONS
What are the major issues taken up by the women's movement over its history?
Solution
The women's movement in India has addressed different issues over time, evolving with the changing social and political context.
-
Nineteenth-Century Social Reform: The 'women's question' first arose as part of the 19th-century middle-class social reform movements. The focus was on reforming what were seen as backward aspects of Indian tradition. Key issues included:
- The abolition of sati (led by Raja Rammohun Roy).
- Advocacy for widow remarriage (led by reformers like M.G. Ranade).
- The fight against child marriage.
- The promotion of education for women (led by figures like Jyotiba Phule and Sir Syed Ahmed Khan).
-
Nationalist Movement: In the early 20th century, women's participation in the freedom struggle grew. The nationalist vision included a commitment to women's equality. The Karachi Session of the Indian National Congress (1931) passed a declaration committing to women's equality, including universal adult suffrage and the right to hold public office.
-
Post-Independence (1970s Onwards): After a lull, women's issues re-emerged in the 1970s with a new focus on 'modern' issues. These included:
- Critiques of the negative representation of women in popular media.
- Addressing the gendered consequences of unequal development.
- Campaigns against violence against women, such as dowry deaths and sexual harassment.
- Legal reforms to change outdated laws concerning women.
-
Contemporary Challenges: In the 21st century, new sites of gender injustice have emerged. A major issue is the declining child sex ratio, which points to a deep-seated social bias against the girl child and the practice of sex-selective abortion.
Still unsure?